Date of publication: March 27, 2000

"Why We Are Black"

There must be something wrong with me, because when I got my census form last week, I dutifully filled it out. That is, until I came to the section marked race. On an impulse, I said that our entire family was black.

We aren't ostensibly black. One look in the mirror confirms that. We are white as sheets, the four of us.

But I did it anyway, probably committing a felony in the process. I can't tell you what the #1 reason was. But I had my reasons, and I will list them here.

1. First, the question bugged me. What do we say about ourselves when we check off a box like that? If you know nothing about me except that I'm white, or that I'm black, how does that help you understand me? In fact, doesn’t it have the opposite effect -- painting me with vague, sweeping probabilities that may or may not be true?

2. I did it out of plantation liberalism, a hard habit to break. What good it will do is unclear to me. My understanding is that the census exists primarily to count citizens so that congressional districts may be accurately apportioned. But what our color has to do with congressional district apportionment is, again, a mystery. Also, minorities get undercounted in the census, and are thus underserved in government outlays. So I thought I'd counterbalance an uncounted black family with our family. Sure, this means fewer benefits for my race, but I figured, Hey, white people had a good year.

3. I always wanted to be black, like in the Lou Reed song -- it's more fun, would be the sanitized reductio. And this seemed like a much easier and more socially acceptable way to go about it than wearing makeup like John Howard Griffin in Black Like Me (1962). And less embarrassing than Al Jolson in The Jazz Singer (1929).

4. I thought it would do my family good. I told my family at supper we would be black from now on. Not that it would change anything in the way we go about our business. But somewhere, on a government mag tape database somewhere, spinning around at a bazillion miles per second, we're black. My family didn’t care.

5. I wanted to show solidarity with my extended family, which is diverse, including great people of numerous stripes and hues, including African-American. To my in-laws Kathy, Seantelle, Neecie, John and Marcus -- this is for you. And to my Uncle Jack, who used to do audiovisual work for Jesse Jackson, and now has a huge adoptive family of folks of color -- I haven't met you all, but I can tell you're terrific.

6. Patriotism. If I have heard anything repeated over and over all my life until it makes me sick, it is that you can be anything you want to be in America. You can be president, or an astronaut, or a cowboy. Well, at the moment I want to be black. So by what right can my country bar me from this ambition? I know this sounds silly, but I mean it. Isn’t this the place that isn't supposed to put a ceiling on your ambitions?

7. Because, scientifically speaking, we are African-American, and so are you. According to the Eve Theory, which is more than just a theory, the entire human race appears to have originated in the DNA of a single woman who lived on the Olduvai Plain 1.5 million years ago. Every living person has DNA that can be traced to her. If that doesn’t make us African, what could?

 

 

 

mfinley.com

COPYRIGHT (c) 2000
by MICHAEL FINLEY

Stimulate the economy, give a poet a dollar.

I enjoyed serving this essay up for you, and I did it for free. But this writer is currently out of work, and a bit of revenue would gladden his heart. If you'd like to contribute to this site, consider dropping a $1 tip in the "Honor Box" here. Just click the CLICK TO PAY image here. Thanks - Mike
Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More
Make payments with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!
Get your signed copy of
The NEW Why Teams Don't Work
by Mike & Harvey Robbins
from Berrett-Koehler Publishers
Just click on the book cover!
A fully revised second edition of this award-winning classic
by Harvey Robbins and Michael Finley
Paperback

Winner, Financial Times/Booz Allen & Hamilton Global Business Book Award, Best Management Book - The Americas, 1995


Table of contents and sample chapters of this book...


Just click on the book cover to order your signed copy for only $12.95.
Make payments with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!
Table of contents and sample chapters of this book...
Why Change Doesn't Work:
Why Initiatives Go Wrong and How to Try Again and Succeed
Harvey Robbins, Michael Finley
Hardcover
Just click on the book cover to order your signed copy for only $12.95.
Make payments with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!
"This is the first treatise on change we've seen that is actually entertaining. The authors cover human and organizational barriers to change and change theories, and then take a tour of management theory that's guaranteed to upset every reader at one point or another." -- HR ONLINE

Table of contents and sample chapters of this book...

Why not bookmark Mike's columns for your weekly enjoyment?

Comments on this column:

This piece got picked up by the March 25 Salon, so we got more thanthe usual number of responses.

Someone at the Race Relations website took serious umbrage at this piece, and used it as a springboard for a rant about census misinformartion. Check it out!


My friend and neighbor on one side is Black (she says she is not African-American because, like Oprah, she doesn't know what tribe/nation her ancestors came from and she can trace her family history back further here in this country than I can). She told me she was encouraged by her minister to say she had five children -- she's single and happily childless -- so 'her people' wouldn't get undercounted on the census. It made her mad as hell.

Interestingly, my wife's Chicano co-worker was encouraged to do the same thing by some of her friends.

It seems to me that, thanks to you, and the constant TV ads, and the strong efforts by the minority communities to "compensate" for supposed undercounting in the past, we Euro-Native Americans (Eastern? Western? Who knows and what difference does this all make? I was born on the Navajo reservation of mixed heritage and look like it) will be the demographic minorities in the future.

Why not just tell the truth? I wonder what kind of subliminal message about honesty you gave your children... M. A.



You are a GEM, Mike. I wish I hadn't already sent in my census form cuz I'd like to be black too...

M.H.


Must admit I was tempted to do as you did, and mark the census for a race or races different than I appear (or am generally thought) to be. I'm related by blood or marriage to all the races, and at least a few dozen national or ethnic groups. I believe if more people knew their true geneology, back more than a generation or two, they might realize that race is an illusion -- a set of physical characteristics fleetingly expressed within a (closed) population. However, I recognize that humans have a strong tendency to point out the "otherness" of other people, whether if be physical, philosophical, or cultural - and to use that as a "reason" to justify all manner of horrible behavior. So many people seem to feel that the only way to build themselves up is to knock down someone else.

R.R.


My husband is black/native American, and so our kids are Jewish/white/black/native American/Hungarian/German/Russian/English and heaven only knows what else. I've decided that you can inherit race from your kids, because I feel distinctly non-white now (a decade after their birth), even though I suspect people still mistake me for some kind of Caucasian. I wish I'd thought to reflect this in my census form. Thanks for doing it for me. Good move, Mr. Finley!

D.A.


Michael, that reminds me of the time we moved from Boston to Birmingham, Alabama. My son, then 16, got a job in a grocery store as a bag boy. One of the other teens made a racial comment, to which he said, "I would appreciate it if you wouldn't say that word...my Mother is black." The kid was quite embarrassed, apologized, and never said that word to Greg again. I'm not black, of course, but I was very proud of my son for saying that. It gives us hope for the future.

A.B.


Loved your "black" thing; it is a trip! Have you read "The Fire Next Time"? I don't know why but I thought of that book while I was reading your e-mail. It is a great book, and I rode a Chicago CTA elevated train with the author-- James Baldwin. I also watched his biography on a recent TV special. It brought back a lot of memories, all of them good. (I never remember the bad memories.) Hahahahahaha. They call it denial but it works for me.

Claire B.


You cheer my heart. We are of the unfortunate few who received the "long form", asking all manner of impertinent and intrusive questions. I have been contemplating putting in erroneous information as a protest, and now you've encouraged me.

A.D.


Sir,

Now you can apply for reparations.

Sincerely,

J. McD.


"Lots of us find it a very helpful, human, sometimes humorous, always interesting, often surprising column that has no peer on the freelance market, And, yes, you can use that as a testimonial if it helps."
-- Bill Dowd, Albany Times Union

"No one talks about the ups and downs of technology like Michael Finley. See his columns online at www.mfinley.com/. -- James S. Derk, Evansville (IN) Courier

"Editors want everything to fall into a neat little box, and your stuff doesn't do that. You don't write merely about technology, you write about what technology means to us and how it has changed us. I like it." -- John Boxmeyer, St. Paul



America's Best-Loved Futurist(TM), Michael Finley has a free gift for visitors to http://mfinley.com.


"A masterpiece of explanatory journalism!" - New Orleans Picayune
"Fast, funny, and highly stimulating!" -Business Book Review

Make payments with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!
Get your signed copy of
The NEW Why Teams Don't Work
by Mike & Harvey Robbins
from Berrett-Koehler Publishers

Just click on the book cover!

Click Here!

HOME | ALL STORIES

Visit Amazon.com

Stimulate the economy, give a poet a dollar.

I enjoyed serving this essay up for you, and I did it for free. But this writer is currently out of work, and a bit of revenue would gladden his heart. If you'd like to contribute to this site, consider dropping a $1 tip in the "Honor Box" here. Just click the CLICK TO PAY image here. Thanks - Mike
Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More

This Week's Top 50 Technology Books